Texas Lawyer Referral Service

The Texas Department of Insurance has adopted new appraisal rules for home and car insurance claims, published in the Texas Register on Friday, November 20, 2026 and effective November 24, 2026. They carry out a 2025 state law, Senate Bill 458. Every covered personal automobile and residential property policy delivered, issued for delivery or renewed in Texas on or after March 1, 2027 must contain an appraisal provision, and under it either the policyholder or the insurer can demand an appraisal when the two sides disagree about how much a loss is worth, without waiting for talks to break down.

Status as of November 20, 2026. Policy can change quickly; the linked official sources are the current word.

Get a Texas Insurance Claim Lawyer — Now

If a Texas insurer has put a number on your storm, flood, fire, hail or vehicle damage and that number does not match what the repair actually costs, an experienced Texas attorney can read your policy and your claim file and explain what the appraisal process, and the rest of the Insurance Code, can do with that disagreement. Call or text 24/7. Get connected with an experienced insurance claim lawyer near you. Our referral service is free for the people we serve.

512-872-4400 · Text Us

What Changed, and When

On November 20, 2026 the Secretary of State published the commissioner of insurance’s adoption of new 28 TAC §§5.9800 – 5.9806, a new Division 4, Appraisal Requirements, in the Texas Register. The adoption was filed with the Secretary of State on November 4, 2026 as TRD-202604618, carries an effective date of November 24, 2026, and was entered under Commissioner Order No. 2026-10210. The proposal had been published on May 8, 2026 at 51 TexReg 3050.

The rules carry out a state law, not a federal one. The Department adopted them to implement Senate Bill 458 of the 89th Legislature, 2025, by Senator Charles Schwertner, which added Insurance Code Chapter 1813, Appraisal of Disputed Losses. The bill took effect September 1, 2025, and Chapter 1813 reaches policies delivered, issued for delivery or renewed on or after January 1, 2026. Section 1813.002 directed the commissioner to write the rules, including the period in which an appraisal has to be finished, and to consider the qualifications and selection of appraisers and umpires.

Why the Legislature wrote it. The Senate Research Center analysis of the enrolled bill describes appraisal as a long-standing feature of residential and personal auto policies in Texas, and states that some companies had moved to take the clause out, including in 2015 when one of the largest personal auto carriers filed and removed the appraisal process for partial vehicle loss. In the analysis’s words, without clear statutory requirements state regulators did not have the authority to mandate access to appraisal in personal insurance policies filed with the Department.

What appraisal is. Section 5.9800 describes it as a dispute resolution process that exists solely to determine the amount of loss when that amount is in dispute between the policyholder and the insurer. Each side hires its own appraiser; if the two appraisers cannot agree, an umpire comes in; and the resulting figure is the appraisal award. It is about the size of the loss, not about whether the policy covers it.

The compliance date moved. The Department had proposed that the new requirements attach on September 1, 2026. In the adopted rules that date is March 1, 2027, which the Department explained gives insurers time to amend their appraisal provisions, write the new notice into their claim-handling procedures, and file the amended policy forms for review and approval before the deadline.

What every covered policy must now say. Under §5.9802, the appraisal provision in a covered policy must:

  • state that either party has the right to unilaterally demand appraisal;
  • not require the parties to reach an impasse before a party can demand it;
  • apply to disputes about the amount of loss, including partial or total loss, other than a total loss by fire subject to Insurance Code §862.053(a);
  • make the award binding as to the amount of loss, unless it was made without authority, was not made in substantial compliance with the appraisal provision, or there was fraud, accident, or material mistake relevant to the appraisal;
  • state the deadlines and process, including the specific time periods set out in §5.9805 for residential property and §5.9806 for personal automobile policies; and
  • not conflict with Division 4 or other Texas law.

A notice has to arrive with the claim decision. Section 5.9803 requires the insurer to provide an appraisal process notice at the same time it sends the acceptance or rejection of the claim required by Insurance Code §542.056. It must be in plain language and at least 10-point type, and it must explain where the appraisal provision sits in the policy, how the policyholder may demand appraisal and where to send the demand, the policyholder’s responsibilities, how to request appointment of an umpire including judicial appointment, the applicable time limits, and the effect of the appraisal award. The Department pointed to its 2024 Appraisal Experience Data Call Report, whose findings indicate appraisal is demanded in only a small percentage of claims, and said policyholders are unlikely to be familiar with how appraisal works or even aware that it is available.

Who may serve as an appraiser or umpire. Under §5.9804, every appraiser and umpire must be competent to evaluate the type of loss in dispute, independent of the parties, and disinterested in the outcome. For a residential property appraisal involving loss to a dwelling, the person must also be an adjuster or public adjuster with experience or training in estimating residential property losses; an engineer or architect with experience or training in residential construction or repair, investigating residential property damage, or estimating residential property losses; or someone who otherwise has occupational experience or training in constructing or repairing the type of damaged property at issue or estimating that type of loss. Policies may set additional qualifications so long as they do not conflict with the division.

The residential clock, in the rule’s own numbers (§5.9805). A demand must be in writing and delivered to the other party.

  • Generally, the demand must be made no later than the expiration of the limitations period for filing suit under the policy. The Department removed the one-year deadline it had proposed and tied the demand window to that limitations period instead, describing the result as keeping appraisal a use-it-or-lose-it option while reducing arguments about dates.
  • If a pre-suit notice is given under Insurance Code §542A.003, an insurer that wants appraisal must demand it no later than 60 days after that notice.
  • If a lawsuit is filed over the loss, the plaintiff may no longer demand appraisal, with a narrow exception where the policy requires an appraisal before a lawsuit may proceed and the policyholder filed suit before limitations ran. A respondent to the lawsuit, other than an insurer that received a §542A.003 notice, must demand appraisal no later than the date the answer is filed or the date the answer is due, whichever is earlier.
  • Within 20 days of the demand, each side must hire its own appraiser and give the other side that appraiser’s name and contact information in writing.
  • The two appraisers must jointly choose an umpire within 15 days. If they fail to, either party may request judicial appointment of an umpire through a county or district court where the residential property is located. A policy may also offer umpire appointment by an independent vendor that provides umpire selection services, but if it does, only the policyholder may invoke that option. A party must give the other party 10 days written notice before requesting an appointment, and a copy of the request.
  • Within 120 days of the demand, the two appraisers must attempt to agree on the amount of loss.
  • Where an umpire is involved, the award must be issued no later than 240 days after the demand. If it is not, the umpire’s engagement ends on that date and the appraisers must choose a new umpire within 15 days.
  • The parties may modify any of these deadlines by written agreement after the insurer provides the §5.9803 notice.

The car-insurance clock runs faster (§5.9806). The personal automobile process has the same shape, the same general demand window tied to the policy limitations period, the same 20 days to hire appraisers and 15 days to choose an umpire, and the same rules once suit is filed. The two differences in the numbers: the appraisers must attempt to agree on the amount of loss within 40 days of the demand, and where an umpire is involved the award is due within 180 days.

What the Department left out. Writing on November 11, 2026, Repairer Driven News reports that the Department received more than 1,000 letters from Texans, and that two changes sought by consumer and collision-industry advocates were made, giving the insured the choice of umpire selection method at the time of dispute and the contractual option to seek judicial appointment, while two others were not: the Department declined to require insurers to disclose financial relationships with listed umpire vendors, and declined to make insurers bear the full cost of a vendor mechanism. Writing on November 10, 2026 in Cozen O’Connor’s Property Insurance Law Observer, insurance litigator Karl A. Schulz reads the rules as real progress while noting that strong ethics rules for appraisers and umpires, limits on umpire fees, and further procedural protections are absent, and that appraisal in commercial claims is left untouched.

Who in Texas This Reaches

The division is statewide and has no county list. It is defined by the kind of policy, not by geography.

  • Residential property policyholders. Homeowners, and the residential property forms generally, for policies delivered, issued for delivery or renewed in Texas on or after March 1, 2027 by the insurers described in Insurance Code §1813.001(a).
  • Personal automobile policyholders, on the same timing.
  • Not covered: §5.9800(c) states the division does not apply to Texas Windstorm Insurance Association policies or to commercial insurance policies. That tracks Insurance Code §1813.001(b). A coastal homeowner whose windstorm coverage is written by the Association, and a small business with a commercial property policy, are outside these rules.

In practical terms, the Texans most likely to meet this process are the ones already living through a disputed repair estimate: the hail and wind losses that run across North and West Texas, the storm and flood damage behind the 2026 disaster declarations in Central Texas and El Paso County, kitchen and roof losses after a fire, and the vehicle valuation fights that follow a wreck. Those claims are where the gap between what an insurer offers and what a contractor charges usually shows up.

What This Changes Legally

It changes what the policy must say, and when the clock runs. Appraisal clauses already exist in the promulgated Texas homeowners and personal automobile policies, and courts have enforced them for decades. What is new is that a covered policy has to contain one, that it has to let either side trigger it unilaterally, that it cannot condition appraisal on the parties first reaching an impasse, that it must reach partial losses and not just total ones, and that it must run on the deadlines in §5.9805 and §5.9806.

Appraisal decides the amount, not the coverage. Both the statute and §5.9800 describe the process as existing solely to determine the amount of loss. Insurance Code §1813.004 provides that an appraisal does not affect any applicable policy terms. Whether a loss is covered at all, and questions such as causation or policy defenses, are not what an appraisal panel resolves.

The award is hard to unwind. Under §5.9802(4), the award is binding as to the amount of loss unless it was made without authority, was not made in substantial compliance with the appraisal provision, or there was fraud, accident, or material mistake relevant to the appraisal. Those are narrow grounds.

The timing interacts with litigation. The residential rules key an insurer’s 60-day demand window to the pre-suit notice under Insurance Code §542A.003, which a claimant must give at least 61 days before filing suit on certain weather-related property damage claims. Once suit is on file, the plaintiff generally loses the unilateral option, and a respondent has until the answer is filed or due. Karl Schulz notes in the Property Insurance Law Observer that the plain language of the deadlines keyed to §542A.003 does not reach claims where pre-suit notice is given under Insurance Code Chapter 541 or the Deceptive Trade Practices Act. How those pieces fit a particular claim is a question about a particular policy and a particular record.

Nothing here is retroactive. Division 4 attaches to covered policies delivered, issued for delivery or renewed on or after March 1, 2027. A claim being handled today is governed by the appraisal clause in the policy that was in force when the loss happened, together with Chapter 1813 for policies issued or renewed on or after January 1, 2026. The new notice requirement and the new minimum deadlines are not in effect for a policy written before the compliance date.

What Kind of Option Might Apply

Whether appraisal helps or hurts in a given claim depends on facts a rule cannot see: what the policy says, what the insurer has already paid and written, what the repair really costs, and how much time is left. Experienced Texas insurance claim attorneys describe working through questions like these with a client:

  • Is the disagreement about how much the loss is worth, or about whether it is covered? The two go down different roads.
  • What does the appraisal clause in this policy actually say today, and what is the limitations period for filing suit under it?
  • Has the insurer sent the Insurance Code §542.056 acceptance or rejection notice yet, and what did it say about the amount?
  • If a pre-suit notice under §542A.003 is being considered, how does that interact with the 60-day window the insurer would have to demand appraisal?
  • Who would be a competent, independent and disinterested appraiser for this type of damage, and what will the process cost?
  • Are there other claims in the file, such as delay in payment or claim-handling conduct, that an appraisal award would not resolve?

An insurance claim lawyer can review a specific policy and claim file, explain what the rules in force for that policy require, and lay out what appraisal would and would not settle. A rule published in the Texas Register cannot tell anyone whether to invoke it; that is a conversation about one claim and one set of dates.

Why Acting Quickly Can Matter

Every deadline in these rules runs from something that has already happened. The demand window is tied to the limitations period for filing suit under the policy, so it shrinks as time passes. An insurer’s 60-day window after a §542A.003 notice, a respondent’s deadline at the answer date, the 20 days to name an appraiser, the 120 or 40 days for appraisers to try to agree: all of them start on a date that is fixed by events, not by when someone gets around to reading the policy.

Texas property claims also carry their own statutory deadlines for prompt payment and for suit, and those are set by the Insurance Code and the policy rather than by this new division. The practical value of talking to a lawyer early is that the dates get identified while there is still room to use them. That conversation can happen now rather than after a window has closed.

Get a Texas Insurance Claim Lawyer — Now

An experienced Texas insurance claim attorney can read your policy, your claim file and your dates, and explain how the appraisal process and the rest of the Insurance Code apply to them. If a lawyer in our network offers an initial consultation, it is free. Call or text 24/7. Get connected with an experienced insurance claim lawyer near you.

512-872-4400 · Text Us

Sources

  1. Adopted Rules, Title 28, Insurance: new 28 TAC §§5.9800 – 5.9806, Appraisal Requirements — Texas Register, November 20, 2026, Texas Secretary of State; adopted by the commissioner of insurance, filed November 4, 2026, TRD-202604618, effective November 24, 2026, proposal published May 8, 2026 at 51 TexReg 3050 (primary document, full preamble and republished rule text).
  2. Commissioner Order No. 2026-10210, Texas Department of Insurance — the order adopting the new sections, with the rulemaking history.
  3. Senate Bill 458, 89th Legislature, Regular Session, 2025, Texas Legislature Online — the bill that added Insurance Code Chapter 1813, Appraisal of Disputed Losses; effective September 1, 2025, applicable to policies delivered, issued for delivery or renewed on or after January 1, 2026.
  4. Senate Research Center bill analysis, S.B. 458, enrolled version — the section-by-section analysis of Chapter 1813 and the statement of legislative intent, including the 2015 removal of the appraisal process for partial vehicle loss.
  5. Texas Department of Insurance Issues New Rules Governing Residential and Automobile Appraisal, Karl A. Schulz, Cozen O’Connor Property Insurance Law Observer, November 10, 2026 — independent legal analysis of the exclusions, the appraiser and umpire qualifications, the deadlines, and what the rules leave out.
  6. Texas adopts final right to appraisal rules with changes following comments, Teresa Moss, Repairer Driven News, November 11, 2026 — independent reporting on the public comment volume, the umpire-selection changes the Department made, the two it declined, and the March 1, 2027 compliance date.
  7. 2024 Appraisal Experience Data Call Report, Texas Department of Insurance — the report the Department cited for the finding that appraisal is demanded in only a small percentage of claims.
  8. Storms and disaster claim help, Texas Department of Insurance — the agency’s own consumer pages on property claims and the claim process.

Find the right Texas lawyer for this: Texas Consumer Protection Attorneys · Texas Litigation Attorneys

English | Español